+- Sinisterly (https://sinister.li)
+-- Forum: Design (https://sinister.li/Forum-Design)
+--- Forum: Feedback (https://sinister.li/Forum-Feedback)
+--- Thread: Rate My Banner? [- RecruitmentChallenge For GFXRoyal -] (/Thread-Rate-My-Banner-RecruitmentChallenge-For-GFXRoyal)
Pages:
1
2
Rate My Banner? [- RecruitmentChallenge For GFXRoyal -] - Town - 12-20-2013
Original
![[Image: a731183b9ce65c5281524b7c0b5a42ac.png]](http://gyazo.com/a731183b9ce65c5281524b7c0b5a42ac.png)
A Little Touch Up
![[Image: 2debd8829cb8ce8602b3c65b4763046e.png]](http://gyazo.com/2debd8829cb8ce8602b3c65b4763046e.png)
hey guys can you rate this banner i made? maybe even give some feedback on it?
A Little Touch Up
hey guys can you rate this banner i made? maybe even give some feedback on it?
RE: Rate My Banner? - Eternal Minds - 12-20-2013
It's fine, but I think that the fire doesn't really fit the theme. Maybe if you lower the opacity of the fire by a bit It'll appeal to me more.
RE: Rate My Banner? - Alex - 12-20-2013
It's not really banner sized at all. The stock is all over the place. Try to clean it up a bit.
RE: Rate My Banner? [- RecruitmentChallenge For GFXRoyal -] - Town - 12-20-2013
(12-20-2013, 07:10 PM)Eternal Minds Wrote: It's fine, but I think that the fire doesn't really fit the theme. Maybe if you lower the opacity of the fire by a bit It'll appeal to me more.
to be honest i was thinking about that, im going to give it a shot and see how it outcomes
(12-20-2013, 07:11 PM)Alex Wrote: It's not really banner sized at all. The stock is all over the place. Try to clean it up a bit.
banners can be any size but i know what you mean
RE: Rate My Banner? [- RecruitmentChallenge For GFXRoyal -] - Eternal Minds - 12-20-2013
It's a little better, but if you look at the fire it looks like you copy+pasted it, you should erase some parts so the fire looks different.
Also, fire always goes in the same direction as the wind. Change the fire so it's pointing to the same direction, to add flow.
RE: Rate My Banner? [- RecruitmentChallenge For GFXRoyal -] - BeastlyHobos - 12-20-2013
Banners usually have a transparent background so im not sure how this could be used. But just a suggestion when you enter I would suggest that you try and fit the design to a smaller width
RE: Rate My Banner? [- RecruitmentChallenge For GFXRoyal -] - Fallen - 12-20-2013
I think it'd be better if you got rid of the black background because it flows in too quickly.
RE: Rate My Banner? [- RecruitmentChallenge For GFXRoyal -] - Art - 12-20-2013
Wooooow! That's a really awesome banner.
RE: Rate My Banner? [- RecruitmentChallenge For GFXRoyal -] - Lone Wanderer_HF - 12-21-2013
No offense but the difference between the original and "touch-up" is a bit more brighter and colours are contrasting more. Can you point out what you actually did?
RE: Rate My Banner? [- RecruitmentChallenge For GFXRoyal -] - BeastlyHobos - 12-21-2013
(12-21-2013, 02:56 AM)Aragorn II Elessar Wrote: No offense but the difference between the original and "touch-up" is a bit more brighter and colours are contrasting more. Can you point out what you actually did?
Yeah i agree i didnt see a lot of difference between
But dude keep up the work and keep doing what your doing
