[mothered]

I agree that it is nonsense and their stubbornness for that PR is ridiculous in this case.
Anyway I could file it, just wanted to keep that option for a larger catch as it would seem suspicious if I'd visit the PD later claiming problems with the same store again

They've asked to file a PR for a reason, namely that they cannot justify their previous statement confirming you've received your Item. If they could, they wouldn't request the report.

I understand your position to not go ahead with It for an Item of that value, but If you do, your SE has a high chance of success.