[mothered]

I don't feel comfortable going into the local police station to file a report. I'm not sure if Toronto has an option to file one online though, that'd be so much better tbh.

Fair enough, I understand your position.

In terms of filing an online report, call the police station and ask whether It can be done. Alternatively, If they have a website, check there.

Is it almost guaranteed that Best Buy will require a Police report for this? If that's the case I might as well go through with Amazon instead

For the most part, yes, however nothing Is guaranteed when SEing.