[mothered]

I don’t mind getting a police report but in the off chance they do investigate I’m kinda screwed. I know my mail man and he gave it to me by hand.

Do you accept the package via an authorized signature?

no he was going to leave it in front of the door but my roommate opened the door.

So what's the Issue?

If the Item was accepted without any form of authorization (or proof of receipt), It's no different to leaving It at your doorstep. The mailman cannot recall each and every event and even If he could, It's his word against yours.