[sinisterlee]

Maybe you can say that there was a crack and that the bottle totally broke at the moment you put it out of the box ?

It's most likely that the seller will ask for a picture.

Alternatively, you can say that there is something wrong with the alcohol and that you got sick for example.

Which company do you want to SE ?

It would have to be more than a hairline crack imo for them to not ask for it to sent back.
Not sure how easy or hard it is to show a significant crack/shattering with photoshop.

Considering alcohol can make you sick and some people are even rather sensitive to it, it could be a bit trickier to pull off that method.
Could be possible by saying that you were immediately sick and telling them how you are familiar with the particular wine/alcohol.

No particular shop in mind. Amazon has some quite expensive alcohol but of course if you want something specific or really high end I would look to an international alcohol shop.

Did you end up trying ?

Not yet, got more alcohol than I need and reselling isn't so easy.