[mothered]

I think you have to consider that aftershave has some sort of alcohol component that makes it evaporate faster than water. So you can't have the box look like it's soaking wet.

Moreover, It may have evaporated In transit, hence there'll be no signs of spillage on receipt of goods.

Be calculated when using this approach by saying that the moment you opened the box and carefully took out the Item, It Immediately started to leak. Photos can be taken thereafter showing full signs of the damage.