+- Sinisterly (https://sinister.li)
+-- Forum: Design (https://sinister.li/Forum-Design)
+--- Forum: Feedback (https://sinister.li/Forum-Feedback)
+--- Thread: Rate this logo (/Thread-Rate-this-logo--87457)
RE: Rate this logo - m0dem - 02-23-2017
I like it! Very clean! 8/10
RE: Rate this logo - Synthx - 02-23-2017
Not bad at all, although I would prefer more there I guess. but looks nice!
RE: Rate this logo - zenith - 02-23-2017
Wh- why is the neck so long
Pretty simple. But I think that's what you were going for. So it's okay.
RE: Rate this logo - Blink - 02-23-2017
I like it, but the words kinda ruin the feel.
At first it seems modern, but the words make it look like a high school football team logo.
RE: Rate this logo - zorrophreak - 02-23-2017
It is very simple, so I think if that is what you were going for, good for you, its not bad.
So as a rating: 7-8/10
Now for the long winded critique:
However, one of the critiques that I have is that if you want simplicity, I'd suggest going all the way. You're too far midway. You could have simplicity like the following logo:
![[Image: 5135.png]](http://gtalogo.com/img/5135.png)
Or you could have a bit complexity with simplicity like this one:
![[Image: Treyarch_Logo.jpg]](https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/0/0a/Treyarch_Logo.jpg){kind=logo}
The thing is that one is simple, but reasonably midway. Too complex doesn't go well in logos, especially not in today's world.
If you wanna keep it simple, try to not have it be just that color set. Its painful and unattractive alone. Try layering it atop a emblem type background, so its not just those colors for the logo.
^ The above is mostly for the logo without text.
For the one with text, as @Ender said:
(02-23-2017, 04:42 AM)Ender Wrote: the words make it look like a high school football team logo.
It looks less like a gaming studio and more like a gaming team, much like a sports team. Less work and more play, which even for a laidback game development team, is bad.
In fact, simply adding a new font may be a good idea, or you could just remove the text in general. Logos tend to look better without text (unless they are text, take DICE and McDonalds for example.)
RE: Rate this logo - Bish0pQ - 02-23-2017
Looks okay, I would rate it 7/10, the colours aren't entirely right in my opnion, with some improvements could be made better.
RE: Rate this logo - Skullmeat - 02-23-2017
The text is a bit much. I'm also not a fan of that font. Try simplifying the design a bit. When it comes to logos its more about quick visual recognition, than it is describing what the product or company is.
RE: Rate this logo - Oni - 02-23-2017
I personally like it. Maybe try other fonts?
RE: Rate this logo - mothered - 02-23-2017
Although a little more creativity would be nice, I do like It's simplicity.
I think there's a lot of constructive criticism that can be taken under advisement.
RE: Rate this logo - DarkMuse - 02-23-2017
It's a good start. It looks like step 2 / 12 however. You need to add a bit more detail and if you're going for a more basic look, there are still ways to add detail while maintaining a minimalist style.