[Eclipse]

Hey guys,

A friend made a logo for a clan. I will not mension his name but here's the logo:



Feel free to post any honest feedback and a rating.

Thanks,
Sparks

[Night Owl]

Bewel filter looks awesome in this logo but i didnt like flat part

[Eclipse]

Bewel filter looks awesome in this logo but i didnt like flat part

Thanks for the feedback. What rating would you give it?

[Night Owl]

Thanks for the feedback. What rating would you give it?

8/10

[cr33pyguy]

It is well done, finished looking, and clearly thought through.

but how would it be used? as a banner, or a logo?
if it's a banner, it should be ok.
for a logo i'd suggest a few things.
- in my opinion the middle with the thick line and the line coming down is a bit messy, it could be better if they were further apart (but I haven't seen that so can't be sure)
- reduce the complexity. a logo is supposed to be something that is easy to recognise, while this is a bit complex (I mean, just like the shadows/highlights)
- the background "flash" light is a bit confusing as it's the same color as the object itself, probably adding to the confusion mentioned in my first point.

That is all...
and they're my opinions